I'm in the process of editing Empty Houses, as I have been for the last few months. I've been getting some wonderful feedback, and am still really enthused about this story and truly believe in its potential. That being said, I've found myself having some thoughts. I'm not the only writer who thinks these things, but I wanted to take a moment to expound on what they mean to me as a writer.
My writing sucks.
We all go through this. You're working hard, proud of your progress, and then all of a sudden, you loathe every single sentence that you see. Every verb choice feels sophomoric, every phrase is contrived, nothing is worth a single damn, and you're the worst writer to ever write anything in the history of literature. You might as well just delete the entire thing and do the world a favor.
But, your writing doesn't suck. It really doesn't. I honestly believe that you can find something redeeming about anything you write. It could be the characters (or even just one brilliant character who sparkles and comes alive on the page), or your plot twist, or even just a single sentence. I don't mean this to be discouraging. Quite the opposite. What I'm trying to articulate is that nothing is worth throwing away. Find the beauty within your own writing. It's there, and even in your darkest moments of self-loathing, you can find that one little thing that will reinvigorate you and your enthusiasm for the project. I promise. I do it all the time.
The best part of all? It's never just one thing, but finding the first can often send you soaring down a path of kick-ass paragraphs, awesome dialogue, rainbows, sunshine, and unicorns wearing party hats.
The moral of this story: Kick your inner Negative Nancy in the ass and send her packing. She's not a good friend, and if you keep her around, neither of you are going to get anywhere.
The people who say they like ::insert project name here:: are just being nice.
No, they aren't. Really, they aren't.
Have you ever had a friend or family member be so excited to show you something that they're so freaking proud of they're practically skipping, and you have to force a smile on your face with every ounce of energy and good will in your entire body? You know what I'm talking about. It could be the painting of their dog that looks more like a sack of sprouting potatoes, or the birthday cake that seems to be channeling the Leaning Tower of Pisa. They can't wait to show it off, and have no idea that it's hideous. But, you know that it's hideous and can't bring yourself to squash all of their hard work and excitement. So what do you do? You find the good in what they're showing you.
"I love what you did with the shading there around the ears... Oh yeah, the nose. I meant nose..."
"It smells delicious!"
You don't say, "OMG! That is the best painting I've ever seen! Send it to the Met. It'll be hanging on the wall next to a Picasso the next time we visit!" or "I'm taking a picture of this and sending it to the Food Network. They'll put you on their next cake challenge show for sure!"
So if someone tells you that they like your story, listen carefully to what they say. Just like you are always able to find the good in those hideous but well-intentioned efforts, they're doing the same for you. Or maybe they really do just love it, love it, love it. If your mom tells you that she loves the story, then she loves the story. It doesn't mean that the writing is perfect and it's ready to get picked up for publication. It means that you have a great story. If someone tells you that Chapter 3 was freaking amazing, then Chapter 3 is freaking amazing. Chapters 1, 2, 4, 100, and 206 might be crap ready for a machete red pen, but Chapter 3 is great stuff.
The moral of this story: The people who read your stories have valid opinions, even if they know nothing about the craft of writing. Listen carefully to the feedback they give you, because they're being as honest as they can be.
Every time I read through it, I find more things to fix.
Yup. You do, and from what I hear from other writers, so does everyone else. Published best-selling authors go through this. That doesn't comfort you? Well, it should.
We're human beings. We're flawed, we're picky, and we're very rarely satisfied. I'm on my second round of edits right now. After the first round, I was feeling great about the story. Note my careful use of the word story. This second round is devoted to tightening up and enhancing the writing. The third round will serve another purpose, not that I have any idea what it is yet. But if you think that means that on the third round, I'll remain stalwart and will refuse to fix a janky sentence or two, you're wrong.
We're never done because there's always something that can be better. We can always improve our craft. This is something that excites me. I love to learn (Yes, I'm a nerd), and the thought that with my hard work and further education I can continue to become a better writer gives me dork tingles all over. If you're writing right now and think there's no way that you could possibly get any better at this crazy thing we all do, then I feel sorry for you. You're setting yourself up for a lot of frustration, pain, and disappointment.
If you do happen to get published some day, someone you meet along the way is going to have suggestions for improvement. It might be line edits, it might be a title change, it might be an addition of a new plot arc to flush out the story. The point is, there's going to be something. But if you already think that you're the best, and that your work is infallible, then you're going to find yourself with a problem. A big one.
Be adaptive. Be accepting of the fact that no matter what, your writing can always be better. If you get published and are lucky enough to be able to go into a bookstore and pluck your novel from the shelf, without doubt you're going to flip open to a page and go "Damn it. I really wish I would've changed that."
The moral of this story: You're always going to want to change things, so all you do is the very best you can every day and work to constantly improve.